Monday, January 28, 2008

Frank Rich: Tool of the Week

With all due respect to my friend the Communications professor, Frank Rich is a moron. And this current article has at least five examples of outright inaccuracy or delusional thinking. I read it yesterday and was half-tempted to write a complete blog, but demurred because I figured it didn’t matter anyway. Conservative Democrats don’t take Rich seriously, Liberal Democrats are so delirious over Obama by now that any fuel to this anti-Clinton fire is superfluous, and Republicans don’t read. But since the good professor brought it up, I’ll try to sum up my thoughts as concisely as possible. I’ll let Dr. S correct my errors.

Rich says, “Do Bill Clinton’s red-faced eruptions and fact-challenged rants enhance or diminish his wife as a woman and a candidate?” The examples of red-faced eruptions, I presume (Rich cites no specifics), are when Clinton called foul on Obama’s self-characterization as an anti-war candidate when he voted for every single war funding bill, including the supplementals. Is this not true? The only difference is that Hillary voted for the 2002 Iraqi Force resolution before Obama was in the Senate. He says he was against the war before that resolution, but we have to take him at his word how he would have voted. Remember that 2002 bill was not a declaration of war, only a consent for president to use force if necessary to carry out UN inspections. Obama was in office when the fighting started and voiced no official dissent (unlike others like Russ Feingold and Chuck Hagel.)

Clinton defends this stance in another clip and sets the record straight on Obama using the race card. I see no “red face” or hear any “rant”; watching the video is important because you can see and hear the tenor of his voice and the smile on his face. He looks like I would imagine any professor would when educating a student on a sophomoric question.

The “fact-challenged rants” I can only imagine (again, Mr. Rich cites no specific “rant”) perhaps refer to Clinton’s assertion of voter disenfranchisement by the Democratic party in Nevada. If you listen to the exchange, Clinton was merely answering a question about a lawsuit filed by the teacher’s union against the Nevada Democratic Party. In the video I see, his face is not red and I sense no rage or even any discontent, only a little impatience, which I think is more than appropriate. [As an aside, when listening to these videos, savor the moment of a president actually speaking in complete sentences—quite a pleasant departure from what we have grown used to, no?]

Okay, Chris, here is my assertion. Jon Stewart on the Dailyshow has put this more succinctly than I could with this piece by Samantha Bee. An entire dialogue is being created here by the anti-Clintonians of an out-of-control Bill Clinton flying into purple rages and making wild accusations about the opposing candidate. Bill is characterized as “red-faced” and “fact-challenged” yet Rich supplies no references. Who’s “fact-challenged” here? But the facts don’t matter because the damage is done by the mere rhetoric of the characterization, and the liberals and Republicans lap it up. The Republicans always believe this stuff-- I can understand that-- after all they’re still eating Karl Rove’s shit sandwiches, but I have to admit that I’m a little disappointed in the Liberal Democrats—they should be smarter than this.

Frank Rich goes on to broach another meme, the so-called Clinton dirty laundry. He says, “Mrs. Clinton repeatedly talks of how she’s been ‘vetted’ and that ‘there are no surprises’ left to be mined by her opponents.” Rich goes on about the Clintons failure to provide a list of contributors to the Bill Clinton Library in Arkansas, and I can just see the glee in little Frank’s pudgy face when he concludes that this is a fatal flaw in Hillary Clinton’s campaign because the names on that list will, I suppose, sink her candidacy. Imagine if we learn that Saudi Arabia gave ten grand, or –heaven forbid!—Merck gave a hundred grand! The horrors! Rich even goes back to the Marc Rich (no relation I presume) pardon for fuel to heap on this inferno of apparent guilt and shame.

Frank Rich says with an apparent sigh, “People don’t change. Bill Clinton, having always lived on the edge, is back on the precipice. When he repeatedly complains that the press has given Mr. Obama a free ride and over-investigated the Clintons, he seems to be tempting the fates, given all the reporting still to be done on his post-presidential business.” Thank God we have Frank Rich to put a fine point on the tactics of the Republican Party operatives – I’m sure most of us, especially the Clintons, were unaware.

The fact is that Barack Obama has not run through the gauntlet of Republican opposition research. After all, the only state-wide election he has won was against the vaunted Alan Keyes—not exactly a tough match. The Rovians will doubtless find all the dirt that is out there, every nickel bag of dope Obama admittedly smoked had a dealer attached. Every ex-girlfriend will have a story and every parking ticket will be investigated. Has Frank Rich already forgotten the 1992 campaign when we heard from Arkansas state troopers, Juanita Broaddrick and assorted unsubstantiated other rape charges? Does Rich already forget the lame 6-year Whitewater investigation, the “murder” of Vince Foster, Travelgate… etc, etc, ad infinitum? Why does Rich think this will be different? Have the Republicans become kinder and gentler?

Obama is a classic old-school liberal, as far as anyone can tell. This week’s endorsement by Ted Kennedy has the conservatives licking their chops—imagine all the ads that are being created as we speak. My guess is that the only way a Republican can win in November is for an inexperienced candidate like Obama to wander naively into the oncoming locomotive of the Republican pro-business juggernaut. So much is at stake in this election, I have every confidence that no stone will be left unturned and Obama may be fried alive if he makes it to the general election.

Don’t get me wrong, I like the guy. He seems smart, charismatic and honest. But my money is on Hillary Clinton for several reasons. You can read them here. Frank Rich needs to get a clue and stop buying into the clichés hyped by the media concerning Bill’s “fact-challenged rants” and “eruptions.” The real fact is that Hillary Clinton does represent the middle way, the moderate problem-solver. Bill was the rare animal who was not only able to get elected, but was also a lucid, capable bureaucrat; not since FDR or (maybe) Ike have we had one of those. I have confidence that Hillary would be a capable president, but the jury is still out whether she can get elected. I wouldn’t bet against the Clintons—or as Frank Rich so cutely puts it, “Billary.” (Calling them “Billary” is just so-o-o clever that Frankie repeats it at least half a dozen times… and even puts it in the title! What a stunning intellect!)

Sunday, January 27, 2008

Economic Stimulus is Really Just Voter Titillation

This week we get to hear another snake oil sales pitch from our Mountebank-in-Chief George W. Bush with his State of the Union address. This time he’s not selling war, fear of terrorism or abstinence. No, this time Mr. Bush is selling television sets.

Apparently the economy is “strong” but now needs an adrenaline shot to help shore up its long term sustainability, or so say administration officials. Hank Paulson, Secretary of Treasury, made the rounds on today’s talk shows to drum up support for our economic growth and the importance of consumer spending and the need for quick passage of Bush’s stimulus legislation. Paulson’s the same guy who called the sub-prime mortgage meltdown “largely contained” last August just before the feces hit the fan, so his economic chops are suspect at best.

My view is that this economy is structurally damaged and a mere spending stimulus is inadequate and counter-productive. I'm no economist, but I see consumer prices skyrocketing while our assets such as housing and retirement accounts are deteriorating. The US dollar, the currency that most of our paychecks are denominated in, has lost 30% of its value in the past few years. Something is broken and the fissure will not be resolved by more consumer spending and, in fact, it seems that without fiscal restraint (ie, quit shoveling money into Iraq for starters), the US economy will collapse and may bring the rest of the world with it.



The US Gross Domestic product is fully 70% due to consumer spending. If the GDP is faltering, the quickest way to make that number look good is to boost spending by a couple tenths of a percent. In George Bush's world, that equates to about 50 million flat-screen televisions.

The problem with this stimulus package, as hawked by the president and deliriously supported by the Democratic congress, is several-fold. First, it is done with borrowed capital. If I told my wife we should re-mortgage the house to buy a 50-inch plasma set, she would freeze our checking account and call my brother to have me committed. In 2001, Bush brokered a similar rebate scheme in order to stimulate a recessionary economy; the difference is that in 2001 we were flush with cash and the “rebate” was truly a refund on over-taxes that had been collected during the boom times.

While many economists seven years ago thought more of the surplus should have gone to re-building infrastructure and paying down the national debt, the idea of “rebate” was not altogether abhorrent in light of a recession. Today, no such budget surplus exists and the “rebate” will be coming from the largesse of the Chinese government and other sovereign banks that are willing to lend us money.

Secondly, the stimulus package that has been marketed is vastly reliant on increasing consumer spending, which already makes up a disproportionate percentage of our GDP, having grown from 66% to over 70% in the last six years. I remember Mr. Bush extolling the virtues of spending our last nickel on Disney products after the 9-11 tragedy. It seems every tough spot calls for a shopping spree.

Third, we have real needs in this country that have not been addressed due to militaristic priorities shoveling our borrowed capital into the Iraqi rat hole. Highways and bridges here are in disrepair and this definitely comes under the purview of the federal government. A Keynesian stimulus that eschews consumer spending and improves our infrastructure and adds broadband to rural areas seems more appropriate, and would lay better groundwork for sustainable future economic growth. New Asian televisions does not. I know the argument is that a Keynesian stimulus is not as immediate as tax rebates, and the appeal to the so-called conservatives is that rebates to tax payers allow the free market determine priorities instead of some behemothic central government. Following that line of irrationality, we would just put every highway engineering project up for local referendum.

Fourth, the rebates aren’t fair. We are ignoring those that have paid the most into the tax system and mailing checks to those who have not. Not that a $600 check is very significant to a couple making over $200,000, but the fact remains the stimulus package smacks of class warfare and pandering. Why would you give a tax rebate check to someone who a) has not paid much tax, and/or b) has no proven ability to properly allocate capital in the first place?

The reason that family of four is living in a single-wide and qualifies for a $2000 “rebate” is because they likely have little ability to understand personal finance from the start, so in what universe would giving them a check make sense? Give them heating oil allowance, or an educational grant, or increase their food stamps… but a check? Please.

Unlike 2001, this is an election year, which means we have a perfect storm that will certainly deplete our Treasury. Every candidate for every office from US President to Paducah County dogcatcher will be rallying for camera time espousing the propriety of cutting checks to everybody… we'll just pay it back later-- with interest.

Maybe George can include a Quick-Pick lottery ticket in each envelope, too.

For What It's Worth: Let's pick a President


Hillary Clinton is my choice for president, but I am quick to say that any of the top three Democrats would get my vote in a general election against any of the current Republican nominees. If I were a dreamer, and why not (?), I would hope for a deadlocked Democratic convention and Al Gore gets drafted, picking Barack Obama as his running mate. But since all my dreams have already come true in this life, I doubt I’m due any more.

Why do I choose Hillary? This is not an emotional decision. I have friends who have expressed visceral beneficial feelings for Barack Obama, and while I do not share those feelings, I respect and understand them. I have a wife who becomes teary at the prospect of a woman president, and while I do not share that emotion, I respect and understand it.

My support for Hillary is very basic. I agree with her entirely on every single issue, and I think she has the nuts to get things done. Period. Additionally, I have to admit that I would get a certain joy in my heart just seeing the verbally abusive band of anti-Hillary varmints go batshit crazy during her Inaugural Address. I fantasize that they’d have to scrape Rush off the pavement after he wanders aimlessly out into traffic in a Vicoden-induced haze. I picture Tom DeLay putting down his bug sprayer just long enough to choke on his own DDT-laced vomit. I would get a half-chub watching Trent Lott’s plastic hair spontaneously combust in angst.

While Obama seems to support many of the same policies, I’m not sure he has the stones to stand toe-to-toe with the creatures of the Netherworld who currently call themselves Republicans. He’s a nice guy, and a smart guy. But he’s just doesn’t seem mean enough or paranoid enough to negotiate his way through the quagmire that he would certainly encounter. As Caroline Kennedy recently pointed out, Barack Obama does seem very much like her father… and unfortunately, we all remember the tragic end to that Camelot. I believe that Hillary knows when to duck.

The United States is at a critical juncture with stepwise disasters, like several slow motion train wrecks, occurring simultaneously on both the domestic and foreign fronts. The current administration has allowed so much to go wrong that it will take a generation of flawless governance to right the ship of state. While I usually do not go in for campaign rhetoric, I admit that I have fallen for Senator Clinton’s riff about experience.

Senator Clinton has been fighting for things like universal health care and fiscal restraint, “third way” Rubinomics, for at least the 15 years that I have been paying attention to her. The picture of her at Nixon’s impeachment trial (pictured at left) in 1974 speaks volumes of her long term wherewithal. While Edwards was chasing ambulances, she was taking these motherfuckers to task. If Hillary didn’t break under the inhumane treatment that she received in the 1990’s, then she is truly bionic. If she wants this job after all that shit, then she deserves it.

A few nuts and bolts. The universal health care plan that Senator Clinton has outlined is exactly the way it should be done. Everybody gets health care insurance, whether it is through an employer or purchased on the open market. Citizens get a choice and the government subsidizes those that cannot pay. People pay what they can, they get care, and doctors get paid. Perfect. Clinton is the only Democratic candidate who does not desire to “expand S-Chip”, she only promises to “protect S-Chip.” I know this is subtle, but there is an important distinction: S-Chip is welfare—a form of Medicaid—and middle class families who make $74,000 per year should not be eligible for welfare. Obama and Edwards are quick to pander on this issue.

I truly believe that Hillary Clinton in the White House will immediately re-establish the United States’ role as the arbiter of human rights in the world. Our allies would undoubtedly accept either Barack Obama or John Edwards as well, but Clinton would be able to quickly garner international support for such things as multinational forces for Iraq, regional summits in the Middle East, international climate treaties and guidance from friends to help us unwind the Guantanamo gulag in an orderly and legal way. The world remembers our commitment in the Balkans under Bill Clinton, and they remember the yeoman’s effort put forth working for peace in Palestine and the success of his expertise in Northern Ireland, a part of the world that is currently enjoying unprecedented economic growth largely due to that peace agreement.

We need an energy policy. We need to rebuild our infrastructure. We need to educate the next generation for a changing world. These have all been neglected for eight long years, and I think that Hillary has the proper balance of left and right cerebral function to formulate complex plans, get legislation written and supported, and begin to solve these problems. Could Obama or Edwards get these things done, too? Sure, I think they probably could, but I have more confidence that Hillary would.

I’m not sure I could physically cast a ballot for a malpractice attorney, but if John Edwards were the nominee, he would get my vote. This election is too important to allow a militarist like McCain in the White House. I’ll be honest, I understand the Constitution’s proscription against a religious test for office, but there is simply no way in hell I would acquiesce to an evangelical minister who eschews evolution and thinks Adam and Eve rode dinosaurs to have control of the most sophisticated military in the world. And guys who wear magic underwear? Likewise, I’m sorry but Romney doesn’t get my vote either. Giuliani? Heck, even the thick-skulled Republican voters have figured out what he’s all about.

Bottom line: we need a Democratic president. None of the candidates are perfect, but they never are. Frankly, I am heartened at the good choices we do have this time around, but I also realize that my judgment may be skewed; heck, even Homer Simpson would look pretty good after watching our current president stumble his way through the last 7 years.

I look forward to a change in the White House. I would be honored to vote for Senator Hillary Clinton for our next president. And I’ll be first in line for Barack Obama in 2016. Al Gore, if not our next president, would certainly look great as Secretary of State or Attorney General... and maybe President Obama can put him on the Supreme Court someday.

Friday, January 18, 2008

China Rising? Umm... Not this year

Under an overturned nest, can there be unbroken eggs?
-- Chinese Proverb



During the past three weeks, two of the smartest and hardest working people at the office have solicited my opinion on Chinese stocks. One wanted to put a lump sum into Baidu (BIDU) at $409 per share and the other was re-allocating an IRA from US Treasuries into an Asia mutual fund. Like me, these folks have no formal training in economics or money management. They are dedicated healthcare professionals who are trudging their way through a depressed Michigan economy and trying to figure out where to allocate their retirement funds-- not so they can have a yacht in the British Virgin Islands, only so they can avoid being a burden on their families when they cannot work any longer.

From a fundamental standpoint Chinese stocks are expensive, trading at 50X next year's earnings, and the chief consumer of China's massive manufacturing base, the US, is heading into a recession. Add to this the tightening credit markets and price controls imposed by the Chinese central bankers and I do not see much short or intermediate upside to investing in China.

From a technical standpoint, the chart looks tired at best, and downright scary at worst:

The FXI, an exchange-traded fund covering the Chinese stock index, has broken down through its 50 and 200-day moving averages and is heading toward September lows. The US market has wiped out all the meager gains from 2007, and China may do something similar.

Add to this scenario the opacity of the Chinese regulatory structure, the unknown unknowns of the political hierarchy, the increasing pollution and public health consequences and a complete lack of a sustainable economic track record, and the risks to investing in China are phenomenal. The Chinese people are great, but their government and regulatory agencies… not so much.

Whether we are trading stocks, investing retirement funds, or monitoring a laboring patient for that matter, it’s all about risk management. Does the potential upside benefit warrant taking the risk? For China, for me, the answer is no way, not today.

Today, BIDU closed at $265, a 35% drop from the solicitation on December 28th. Investment counselors may downplay such losses as “looking at the short term” when retirement is 20 or more years away. I say Bullshit. A 35% haircut is a real loss of your hard earned scratch, and it hurts. Period.

If China flounders, then the bull market case for liquid and grain commodities completely changes. Oil has been trading close to $100 per barrel partly because the continuing demand of a booming Chinese is baked in. The same goes for agricultural grains, fertilizer and equipment. If the Chinese economy rolls over, the demand structure is gone for these things. Monsanto (MON) and Deere (DE) have had great runs the past year, but their fundamental and technical analysis is changing rapidly.

The US dollar (see below) is bouncing off multi-year lows, but seems to have bottomed from a technical standpoint and may see some strengthening real soon. This does not portend well for US exporting companies that benefit from a lower dollar. Without a burgeoning Chinese middle class and a weak US dollar, Deere (DE) will not be selling as many tractors and combines.

Giving financial advice can be more difficult than giving medical advice. The losses are real and the pain can be exquisite. Always mitigate risk. Always. Sure we’ll miss some opportunities, but there will always be others. I've made some gains in Asia the past couple years, but that horse has run, my friend. Sometimes US Treasuries are okay… even if retirement is 20 years away.

The only Chinese you should even think of buying is the Moo-Goo-Gy-Pan at Chinn-Chinn’s this weekend.

Be careful out there.

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

Is the NAZ oversold yet?



This is an odd little indicator that measures how many stocks in the index are above their 50 day moving average. As negative as the market has been, the NASDAQ may be approaching oversold conditions with only 20% above their 50 MA.

This tool is extremely good in determining oversold conditions during a bull market with the 200 day moving average on the upslope, but the indicator breaks down as the market turns bearish. In other words, at the short term market lows of August and November, the indicator worked beautifully in picking the bottom at oversold levels, but now the 50 day MA line is in a sharper down slope and even though the number of stocks below this number is increasing rapidly the index is declining further.

The question remains, is the market oversold?

The short answer is yes, especially the NASDAQ, but the longer answer is that market sentiment is so lousy that picking the bottom may be very tricky. The NYSE is less clear on this issue; the financials, if this indicator were available, may be the most oversold at this juncture but the 50 day MA is in too sharp a decline to take that bet.


If stocks must be bought at this juncture, I'd stick to lower risk big cap techs: MSFT, ORCL, IGM. Big cap financials like JPM, WB and GS seem okay in anticipation of a rate cut, but that bet is more specious. Regional banks and anything having to do with consumer spending, especially restaurants, need to be sold yesterday. Take your losses now. And don't even get me going on emerging markets... US consumers are running out of credit to buy those cheap plastic doo-hickeys and tainted toys from the Far East... I'm sticking with my Ultrashort China ETF (FXP).



Saturday, January 12, 2008

Jimmy has the Answers...


I Got What America Needs Right Here


Read it here.

Yea! Movies on your Phone!!

David Lynch, three-time Academy Award nominated director, as well as creator of cult classics Eraserheads and Twin Peaks, endorses the iPhone.


Monday, January 07, 2008

Sunday, January 06, 2008

Obama vs. McCain

As the primaries begin, the odds are that the race will be Barack Obama (D) vs. John McCain (R). Taking the long view, this is a beneficial development since this slate will obviate the need for me to put my house up for sale during the current Michigan economic depression. I can live with either of these guys as president. Romney or Huckabee get elected? I’m not sure I can pay taxes to a republic that could elect such people. Seriously.

For no other reason than Hugh Hewitt thinks Romney will be the next president, I now know that the Mittster is history. From the Iraq war to immigration to tax cuts, HH has been so wrong on so many opinions and prognostications that the mind boggles. Hewitt’s brand of stupid is the same that brought us 8 years of Dubya and, if you’re old enough, 6 ½ years of Nixon. It’s amazing to me that someone can actually make a living as a political pundit with such a track record of ineptitude about politics.

If you’re thinking Mitt Romney is your guy, then you probably aren’t informed about his shameless bloviating and prevarication. But then, Republican voters don’t seem to care much about such piffle.

So that leaves us Saint John McCain to win New Hampshire because there is no way those voters will go for the underlying insanity that is Mike Huckabee. An evangelical minister in the White House? Haven’t we already done the Dumb and Misinformed Guy as President thing, and isn’t it playing out as a disaster? The staid New Hampshire voters will put a stunning halt to the ersatz Huckabee juggernaut, which is proof enough that there is indeed a God.

No matter. If Iowa is any evidence, a Republican winning the Presidency in November has about as much chance as Barry Bonds being the next CEO of Pfizer. Over 70% of the votes cast in the primaries and caucuses were for Democratic candidates, so this country’s conservative heartland obviously ain’t buying the GOP’s bullshit anymore. (You may have asked, what the hell took them so long...?) This is the first time in modern history that both the Republican and Democratic primaries have been contested during the same presidential election, so history of sorts was made.

If I had to vote today with the current choices* still in the race, I’d rank them thusly:

  1. Clinton
  2. Obama
  3. McCain
  4. Paul
  5. Richardson
  6. Edwards
  7. Move to Canada, Cost Rica or Australia.

Michigan is a cross-over state, which means that voters can choose which party’s primary participate in, and may cross over to vote for any candidate in either party. Any of the Democratic presidential candidates will be fine, so just as in 2000, I may choose to vote for John McCain in the primary in order to do my part to prevent another presidential disaster (or a capital loss on my house.)


*Sadly, Dodd and Biden, either of whom would have made an excellent candidate, have pulled out of the race as of Friday.

Tuesday, January 01, 2008

War. Really, What is it Good For?

Never underestimate the wisdom of Fred, especially when he is debating an imbecilic REMF.


This sums up the purpose of our military better than anything I've ever read.


[Hat tip: The Cunning Realist.]

Saturday, December 29, 2007

Depp and Burton make a Masterpiece

Tim Burton’s latest film, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, the morality play of revenge set in 19th century London, may represent a new genre of film. It contains the dark cartoonish stylings that Burton is known for, but Todd is a musical, described as a black operetta.

Accomplished actors make the film. Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham Carter are outstanding actors-- as well as singers it turns out. Burton wanted actors who could sing instead of the converse and the play-turned-movie responds well to the elements of style, acting and music. The New York Times correctly calls it “a masterpiece.”

The Los Angeles Times reviewer praises the screenplay and the Stephen Sondheim soundtrack for its fidelity to the stage version. While an R-rated musical may not have broad enough appeal to be a financial success, Sweeney Todd is an excellent film. It’s different from most movies I’ve seen and perhaps the most entertaining in years.

Sunday, December 16, 2007

Boom go the Kurds

Not sure what to make of this item. On the one hand the PKK is a Marxist terrorist organization that smuggles weapons and heroin and has killed thousands of civilians. On the other hand, the US has poor credibility in taking sides on such issues, has also provided weapons to specious organizations and has also killed thousands of civilians.

I do know that military incursions into the only relatively peaceful enclave in Iraq does not speak well of the supposed US diplomatic efforts to quell the mayhem in the region. The Bush administration is attempting to run out the clock on Iraq and hand it off to the next president. Scenes of Turkish war planes strafing villages with US bombs and intelligence will not play into that strategy very well.

Oh, and look for oil and gold to rise next week, especially if Putin takes this opportunity to reinvigorate Cold War tensions.

Hey, Leahy, Act Like You Have a Pair!

Maybe if Patrick Leahy, Chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, visualized everything coming from the White House as coming from Dick Cheney, he wouldn’t be as conciliatory. Cheney after all is the same guy who invited Leahy to have sexual relations with himself back in those heady days when the Republican Party controlled both houses of Congress.

Those days are gone, and bygones are not always meant to be bygones. If a Senate Committee Chairman had balls, he would subpoena those White House officials in connection with any one of the multitudes of alleged crimes committed. Or, if no crimes are suspected, they should all just shut up and go fuck themselves.

The fact is, the Democratic party leaders are calculating. If too much is made of the investigatory mayhem and the election year is filled with endless hearings and squabbles over executive privilege to the point of a Constitutional crisis, then the public may lose patience with the Democratic party and the sure Democratic win for president next November will be lost. The calculation is that by sitting tight and making no waves the Democrats will have both houses of Congress and the White House, and then real change can occur. To inflict the nation with divisive investigations would be counter-productive.

As Uncle Harry and Aunt Nancy calculate, the rule of law burns. Only the latest alleged travesty is the destruction of evidence in the CIA torture escapade. We know that tapes of terror suspects’ interrogations have been destroyed, and we know that the executive branch was implored by a US District judge to maintain said tapes in safekeeping as evidence for future use. The only question that remains is who destroyed the tapes and under whose order. A crime has clearly been committed, now who is to blame?

In an unbelievable request, the president has asked the Senate to stay away from the ongoing investigation by the US Attorney General Michael Mukasey (shown at left with his boss) and the CIA. This is the same president who said that anyone who had divulged the name of Valerie Plame would not be working in his White House, and then proceeded to stonewall the investigation and commute the sentence of a convicted perjurer for political reasons. This is the same White House whose officials are currently in contempt of Congress for failing to show for subpoenas in the US Attorneys firing imbroglio. The executive branch is not to be trusted with any investigation of itself, as stipulated in our Constitution.

Who gave the order to destroy the CIA interrogation tapes? If Leahy will not investigate, and the Democratic leadership does not insist on hearings, then it’s hard to support this charade called government. At some point the rule of law should take precedence over the rule of politics.

Grow some ‘nads and issue more subpoenas. It’s my government and I want to know. Now.

Friday, November 30, 2007

Let's end the misery... put Hillary in the White House

Can't we just put Hillary in the White House now and get on with governing this nation?

I’m no obstinate Hillary fan by any means, but a couple things have led me to the conclusion that we would be better off with another Clinton presidency, and the sooner the better.

Mideast Peace. We currently have an alignment of the stars that represents a fleeting chance to achieve something substantive in the Palestinian “situation.” Ehud Olmert and Mahmoud Abbas are the most moderate respective leaders of Israel and Palestine in generations. They are willing to talk, to summit and even to appear with George W. Bush—all very high risk behaviors—in order to pursue the greater good of a peaceful two-state solution in the Levant. This is big stuff. After seven years of outright neglect, the US has been forced to host the summit in Annapolis. Our president, ever the gracious host, showed up briefly for a photo-op and managed to mispronounce not just one, but both leaders' names in the space of 30 seconds. Idiot. Bush should go away. Now. He has no intention of putting any effort into anything else and Israeli-Palestinian peace is too important and too achievable to leave it to such a simpering dolt. Bill Clinton was known for his detailed understanding of the conflict; even knowing which Jerusalem streets bordered key neighborhoods. He brokered the peace in Northern Ireland that has garnered him rock star status there for their burgeoning and booming economy. Let’s see if Hillary can do the same for Israel.

The other Democrats. Let’s face it; no other Democrat has a real chance of winning the nomination. Sure, I may prefer Biden or Dodd or Richardson, but they aren’t going to make a big push to challenge Senator Clinton. Obama seems smart, but he’s has no chance of manufacturing a winning coalition to beat Hillary. Come back in 8 years when you have more gravitas and Senatorial stature. Hillary Clinton, while not the perfect candidate, is intelligent, thoughtful and has the right connections to turn this ship of state around. Every candidate has flaws, but none of hers are fatal. The issue of perceived unelectability is a sham. Yeah, there are a lot of people who hate Hillary, who loathe her very protoplasm. She evokes a visceral response from a significant number of voters. Just as Tucker Carlson was making this very point last night, it occurred to me… who gives a shit? Tucker isn’t voting for Hillary anyway, or Biden or Obama or any Democrat, ever, so who gives a rip what he thinks of Hillary’s “electability.” And that goes for anyone delusional enough to have voted for George W. Bush or old man Bush for that matter. Heck most of those people, if they’re old enough, were so bent that they voted for Dick Nixon-- Dick Nixon for crissakes!!--so how can their opinion possibly be trusted—or even considered? It’s time to take this country back and cast such lunatic worries—such as caring what the Republicans will think—aside. One part of me wants Hillary elected just because it will piss off as many Republicans as possible.

The Republican candidates. The frontrunners are the most ragtag cast of losers and miscreants ever assembled. Seriously, are Republican voters that cynical that they can keep a straight face and vote for Giuliani after all the hell that was raised over Bill Clinton’s extra-marital tryst? Giuliani kept his mistress holed up on Long Island with police protection while he went through a messy divorce. New Yorkers hated Rudy up until 9-11, and then they still voted him out of office. Romney has flipped more times on more issues than Aunt Jemima has flipped pancakes. Sleepy Fred Thompson still thinks we’re at war with the Soviet Union—just what we need: yet another ill-informed, lazy old white guy who overplays his “aw shucks” persona at the expense of realpolitik. The only reasonable candidates are Ron Paul who at least is a consistent conservative, and John McCain who inexplicably cannot find traction in this field of incompetents. Whichever candidate slitherss out of this quagmire of misfits surely will have no ability to rouse the base into going to the polls next November. But, whatever.

It’s way too early to become too invested in the day-to-day battle for the White House, but certain issues make the status quo shameful. Bush obviously is the lamest duck president in history with no hope or inclination to improve his legacy. His major concern is now how much money he can make on the lecture circuit, “you know, to replenish the ol’ coffers.” While our soldiers continue to die in his war and taxpayers continue to pay off his debts, we can all rest easy that George’s “ol’ coffers” will be replenished—I know that was your greatest concern.

My personal wet dream is that the current Democratic Congressional leadership grows the gonads in the next few months to impeach Bush and Cheney for high crimes against our Constitution, spying on American citizens, holding prisoners without counsel, torturing prisoners against the Geneva Conventions and disenfranchising voters. Will that happen? Doubtful, but I can dream. I have to say that Pelosi and Reid have been a disappointment to me. While their majorities are thin, they do have control of committee chairmanships, which gives them the power of the subpoena, and they have not taken advantage of this gambit. My preference would have been to bring this government to a screeching halt while the rule of law was rammed up the administration’s collective asshole; but that was not to pass and it’s hard not to grow cynical.

Now we have to endure Karl Rove rewriting history instead of reviewing his defense briefs. In his laughable account of the run-up to the Iraq war, Rove claims the Bush administration asked for restraint on the Iraq Force Resolution in 2002, but the Congress passed the Iraq force resolution anyway thus painting poor old George W. Bush into a corner. Ha! Welcome to 1984 and George Orwell's memoryhole. And tell me again why Karl Rove is even allowed to walk the streets without being spat upon in castigation?

Reasonable people cannot try to appeal to such a moronic subculture that would accept Rove, Cheney, Bush, Rumsfeld and Rice as viable leaders. This same subculture should be marginalized and ignored. We have been thrust into a war that has enriched all the wrong players: private contractors (ie, mercenaries), tribal warlords and oil sheiks whose petrodollars have an uncanny way of showing up in support of terrorism. Our tax dollars have been flushed down the rathole with no prospect for any return on the investment. Our soldiers have been killed and maimed while no political or diplomatic solution is proffered.

Next November a Democrat will certainly be elected President. That Democrat will likely be Hillary Clinton. Can’t we just put her there now to get a head start on the godawful mess she’ll need to cleanup?

Sunday, November 04, 2007

"Terrorist Busters"

Unfortunately, I am not making this up. Your CIA is hard at work ensuring that while the free world may still be struggling in the War on Terror (TM), at least we'll have a cool logo:




Not to be confused with this:



... and Ray Parker Jr is currently writing a song that will be sung during the 7th inning stretch of every major league baseball game next season.

Sunday, October 28, 2007

Vince (1929- 2007)


By all accounts Vince spent a life of intellectual pursuits. He was a high achiever in academic studies, having graduated in the top of every class of which he was ever a part. He trained in specialty medicine and practiced radiology for a couple decades. In his fifties, ever the student, he went back to complete a 3 year residency in psychiatry which was his first love. When Vince had finished medical school in the 1950’s the field of psychiatry was still nascent, offering only crude pharmaceuticals and questionable therapies such as electroshock. Vince, instead, chose to study the burgeoning area of radiology and subsequently spent the 1960’s and 70’s and 80’s taking part in the introduction of exciting technologies such as CT scanning, MRI’s, ultrasound, and mammography.

By the mid-1980’s, psychiatry had come into it’s own. New insights and pharmaceuticals had revolutionized the practice of general psychiatry. Locked wards were being emptied out and adult programs were mainstreaming otherwise debilitated individuals into the workforce. Vince enjoyed psychoanalysis as well as medical management, and enjoyed the discussion of the controversies just as much as the practice of the art. He operated his storefront office in the south suburbs for a decade and served his “carriage trade” of professionals and working class alike.

This past week, I have received correspondence about Vince from his siblings. He was the older brother to three sisters, all remarkable people in their own right. They relate the quiet thoughtfulness of their brother, which was often unnoticed amid all the boisterous verbal sparring that marked Vince’s demeanor. His letters home from military service, his advice about academic studies, the respect he showed only in private times were all heartfelt examples of the genuineness of Vince’s approach. He wasn’t one to burden an event with sentimental fluff or diplomatic tact; he always said what he meant to say. Always. For better or for worse. If you were acting stupidly or your argument was flawed, Vince was the one to point that out, but that didn’t necessarily indicate that his intentions weren’t pure.

Vince was a complex person. He loved opera, Carl Jung and was a lifelong student of the panoply of religious thinking and experience. One of my earlier memories of my dad was attending a Unitarian service with him of the rock opera Jesus Christ Superstar in the 1970’s. The music was set to a slide presentation showing recent examples of betrayal, suffering and redemption. To me, it was a bit scary and overwhelming and afterward my dad put his arm on my shoulder and said that we should all use this Jesus figure, whether it’s fictional or not, as an example by which to live our own lives. And he wiped a tear from his eye, smiled, and then added, “you know, except for that crucifixion part.” He studied the Dalai Lama’s teachings and praised Martin Luther King’s rhetoric long before they had become the icons known today.

He was a student of Buddhist thought and practice, being sure to remind anyone that he preferred the Mahayana over the Theravada. He revered earth religions of various aboriginal cultures. He was well versed in Hindu symbolism. He could give hours of lectures on the pagan mythology, and did. As a modern day William James, Vince saw the interconnection of the various religions and spiritual practices among all the people of the world. He saw value in the Pope’s teachings and those of the lost Gospels and the Bhagavad Ghita, as well the value of the accessibility of even scurrilous self-promoters like Wayne Dyer or Werner Erhard.

When I was going through one of those mundane existential crises of late adolescence, Vince sat me down for a series of rather long fatherly discussions. (We rarely had many “short” discussions.) He showed me the similarities between prayer and meditation… and the differences. I learned the virtue of ceremony; the purpose of the Eucharist; the universality of the idea of salvation. Whether you were a Cherokee warrior living in 17th century America or a Ming Dynasty peasant or an Episcopalian from Naperville Illinois, religious experience and purpose had certain distinct similarities. Vince could synthesize the important tenets of the sundry practices and distill them into a useful instruction for every day life. Just as any physician will pursue all avenues for the benefit of his or her patient, he used his immense intellect to help people, not the least of whom was his son. Most importantly, I learned that my Dad cared.

There were other sides to Vince to be sure. He was one of the first Trekkies, never missing an episode of the fairly unpopular series during it’s first run. I remember sitting in Gram and Pop’s kitchen on Damen Avenue with my Dad watching Captain James T. Kirk seducing some bizarre alien on black and white television. Who knew that franchise would take off?

Nobody laughed harder at the Three Stooges than Vince. If he caught me or my brothers watching the old re-runs, he would roll his eyes and scoff at the “stupid” (always pronounced STOO-pid) antics, but within a few minutes he wouldn’t be able to hold back his chuckles when Moe pulled out Larry’s hair in anger or when Curley did the circle dance to his trademark woop woop woop. Likewise, Ralph Kramden was one of his heroes as well as Archie Bunker, and he even got a kick out of the puerile cartoon Beavis and Butthead.

As a kid, some of my fondest memories were vacations with Vince. One trip when I was 15 years old was out West to see the Badlands and the Arizona desert. The whole family, sans my sister, went on the camping excursion through the Dakotas and Wyoming and then headed south to the Grand Canyon. I remember July Fourth 1976, the Bicentennial, in a small town in Minnesota. The fireworks and flags and patriotism of small town Americana were special.

As we drove to see Mount Rushmore and Wall Drug and the other obligatory sites, Vince would entertain with his endless barrage of corny jokes and songs (he was his father’s son, after all). Do you know what they call Holiday Inns in Hawaii? he would ask. “Hula day Inns!” Of course, he would repeat this every single time he saw a Holiday Inn sign. Do you realize how many Holiday Inns there are over the 3000 miles of Interstates we traveled? But we laughed every time he said it, and would secretly hope he would miss the next sign as we saw it in the distance… he never did.

We stopped at a small gas station on some back road outside of Rock Springs Wyoming. The owner was a grizzled WW 2 vintage guy with a buzz cut and a silent and stern countenance. His wife was an Asian woman of the same age who, despite probably living here for 20 or 30 years, spoke very little English. Dad pointed out that they probably met during the war and he brought her back to run the station. She was the friendly one, asking us where we were headed and making other small talk. We told her we were on our way to Utah and Arizona before going back to the Midwest. “Oh! You go to OOH-tah? OOH-tah HOT! You go to OOH-tah, yes? OOH-tah HOT!! HOT!!” I could see the half-smile erupt over Vince’s face as he filed that away for later.

The next night we camped at about three thousand feet in some Utah State Park. Temperatures plunged to the unseasonable 30’s overnight and the next morning Vince was up bright and early making coffee and ripping open the canvas flaps of the trailer tent and throwing off our thick quilts. As the frigid air singed my bare legs and butt, Vince’s demonic cries could be heard through the piercing cold. “OOH-tah HOT!! Oh! You go to OOH-tah? OOH-tah HOT! You go to OOH-tah, yes? OOH-tah HOT!! HOT!!” Then he would clap his hands in rapid succession like a drill sergeant until we were all up, dressed and packed for the road.

Vince was a political junkie. He would read any number of commentary magazines from the conservative National Review to the liberal The Nation, and everything in between. The 1980 Republican convention is a particular memory. He had an admiration for Ronald Reagan’s simplicity and forthrightness, but feared his henchmen in the White House. As usual, Vince’s admonitions were correct as the duplicity of Reagan's staff became known during the Iran-Contra hearings to the regret of the entire nation.

As the years went on, Vince became even more liberal in his thinking and while always the pacifist, he began to see the increasing value of the government’s role in taking care of those who cannot care for themselves. Health care is and should be a right. Education should be free, not only for the benefit of the poor, but for the enlightened self-interest of the entire planet. He was a fan of Kurt Vonnegut’s and Joseph Heller's anti-establishmentism, and was one of the first to protest the Vietnam War. As part of his protest, he refused to get a haircut in the 1970’s until the war ended, to the dismay of his buttoned down medical group. Question authority. More recently, Vince held a special animosity in his heart for George W. Bush.


Vince lived the life that he chose to live. He was blessed to have the devotion of a beautiful wife. His only requirement of his children was that they follow their own happiness.


~~~~~~~

I vividly remember the pride my dad showed when he himself hooded me at Rockefeller Chapel upon my graduation from medical school. Since then we have had the distinct bond that only comes from the fraternal relationship among physicians and surgeons. He certainly loved me my whole life, but I always felt that a particular respect was born on that special afternoon. His smile was a little wider than usual and his hug was a little tighter. Vince has always been my ideal for what a physician should be.

I miss my Dad. Needless to say he has been a big part of who I have become (the good parts anyway.) I think about him and feel his presence everyday. These last couple years I have increasingly missed his words of wisdom, his smile and wit, and his unfailing willingness to tell me when I have been wrong and when I have been right. In many many ways, he was my rock.

My Dad always challenged me to use my brain, but did not hesitate to bare his soul to me as well. I could always do better and be better, but his love was unconditional. Vince was never afraid to give his opinion on any matter of things, and whether you agreed with him or not, you knew that his opinions were always well-considered. Vince is my ideal for what a father should be.

I love you, Dad. And if there is a heaven, I know you are there.

And on the off chance that there is indeed a God, well… good luck, God… and please take care of him.

Saturday, October 13, 2007

The Victimization of Graeme Frost

The national debate about health care is reaching new lows with each heart-wrenching chapter, the latest is the Graeme Frost Tragedy. Graeme is a hero, no question. He has endured more than any 12 year-old should. He appears to be a smart kid who is articulate and by all accounts hard-working. He sustained life-threatening injuries and was hospitalized and still undergoes therapy. Now he has has been subjected to the circus of our pop culture punditocracy. It's an atrocious spectacle by any measure.


Paul Krugman, with whom I agree on nearly every issue, has taken the opportunity to pen a column on the “Sliming of Graeme Frost.” When I saw the title I fantasized that Krugman was taking his sharp aim at the true culprits in this crime, but alas, he has instead emptied is revolver on the easier, albeit improper, target. Instead of holding our congressional leaders to task, he spent precious ink blasting the right wing noise machine.


Graeme Frost bravely and with the precious naivete of a good kid went before the nation to represent the Democrats in the Saturday radio address last week. He was also trotted out in front of the TV cameras with Uncle Harry and Aunt Nancy for a photo op in support of the expansion of the S-Chip grant to provide health care for the working poor. To the feigned surprise of all, the vile right wing misanthropes stalked the Frost family and found all the dirt they could, true or not, that could be printed and screamed over the airwaves. Harpies like Michelle Malkin and blowhards like Rush Limbaugh have sold ad time with their baseless campaign to smear the Frost family. Hmmm, who could have predicted that?


Unfortunately, economist commentators such as Krugman have made this debate as much about the sliming of Graeme Frost as about the true debate, which is the unsustainability of the current health care system and ways to fix it. He should know better, and more importantly our Democratic leadership should know better-- and do better. And we rely on writers like Krugman to provide comment about our political leaders, not about the misbehavior of Limbaugh and Malkin.


If Pelosi and Reid would spend more time noodling the health care crisis and crafting legislation to provide a comprehensive program for all Americans and less time pandering to their constituents and subjecting kids like Graeme to the venom of right wing morons, then maybe we could actually accomplish a sustainable fix to the problems we have. And why doesn't Krugman recognize this?


Graeme said, "Most kids my age probably haven't heard of CHIP, the Children's Health Insurance Program, but I know all about it, because if it weren't for CHIP, I might not be here today." While this kid may believe this, it isn't exactly true. Emergency care is always provided regardless of the patient's ability to pay. Without S-Chip, Graeme's father Halsey may have been sent a bill, he may have had to sell some of his assets, he may have had to even file for bankruptcy but the fact is that Graeme would hve gotten the care he needed with or without S-Chip. The drama may get votes for Democratic candidates, but it moves us not one inch closer to a solution.


As the New York Times points out: Under the Maryland child health program, a family of six must earn less than $55,220 a year for children to qualify. The program does not require applicants to list their assets, which do not affect eligibility. The TIME coverage points out: “In short, just as the radio spot claimed, the Frosts are precisely the kind of people that the SCHIP program was intended to help.” Exactly. The Frosts qualified for the old version of S-Chip. The expansion of coverage into the middle class is not necessary to provide for working poor families like the Frosts. The Congressional plan which was vetoed by George W. Bush is an expansion of the grant program to give benefits to more middle class folks, so why is this family's plight even relevant?


Hasn't Graeme Frost been through enough already, and shouldn't his parents know this? Halsey Frost is a father who cannot provide for the basic needs of his large family-- fine; but the least he could do is protect his kids from the cruel vagaries of our grotesquely partisan political system.


Halsey Frost, Graeme's father, bemoans his family's situation, “We work hard, we’re honest, we pay our taxes. There are hard-working families that really need affordable health insurance.” First of all, let's be honest: Mr. Frost does not pay taxes, or at least not a significant amount of federal taxes, which is the pool that covers this grant program. By my estimate, assuming a standard deduction, the very most the Frosts' pay in federal income tax is $1300 per year, but most likely they pay nothing. Halsey is correct that working families need affordable insurance; S-Chip is not the answer mainly because it is not insurance, it's welfare.


Certainly through no fault of their own, the Frosts were not asked to pay anything for their health care coverage. The federal legislation is based on self-reported income and does not require premiums or co-pays (although states have some latitude) or listing of his assets. How much did the Frosts pay for their S-Chip coverage? My guess is very little, if anything. Now we are going to expand this program to middle class families with no requirement to pay tax or premiums? Suppose Frost's business takes off and he enjoys more success in the years ahead. Would he have incentive build more equity in his business in lieu of salary, thus perpetuating his welfare status? Would other more prosperous families who are close to the S-Chip income cut-off be tempted to work less in order to get these benefits?


In short, this debate has been side-tracked by the completely predictable sliming of Graeme Frost, and the counter-sliming of the right wing idiocracy by the Democrats. What this country needs is a comprehensive health care policy, as every other developed nation has, and the debate needs to be managed by the adults in our congressional leadership and not some well-meaning kid who would be better off in school. The current health care patchwork with it's creeping reliance on welfare and now pandering to the middle class and the glorification of victimization is simply not sustainable.



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

My next post will attempt to flesh out the requirements of a national health care policy. Be patient, there are no easy answers. A note to Anonymous: this is not about me. I'm not a pediatrician or even a primary care doctor, but I do recognize the obvious, and the obvious is that in real dollars primary care doctors' salaries have dropped, residency programs cannot convince medical students to pursue these careers and a shortage of these physicians is worsening.




Tuesday, October 09, 2007

S-Chip is Not Insurance-- it's Welfare

(If you want to cut to the chase, then skip to the last bullet point at the end.)



I'm all for providing health care for kids. Everyone's kids. As long as we're at it, let's get health care for everyone. Period. Even the adults. Old people, vets, the indigent, the disabled and now kids are all included, which leaves only adults being uncovered by government programs. So why not cover all adults as well? Universal health care is certainly a worthwhile endeavor, and before I'm asked to pay for able-bodied middle class parents' kids, I'll ask to be included myself. Short of that, I'll vote no on middle class kids' being on the dole, because that is definitely what the expansion of S-Chip is when it includes those families living at 300% of the poverty level.

Seniors have paid their Medicare payroll taxes so they deserve the benefits as contracted. Likewise for vets. The indigent and disabled need care as part of our social moral imperative. But families living at 300% of the poverty level should be responsible for their own kids' health care expenses. That's my opinion. If we want to expand the program to middle class kids, then let's just go to Nationalized Health Care altogether, for everyone.



I know the responses:

  1. The Practical Approach. “The cigarette tax pays for it.” The proposed increase of $35 billion dollars over five years in this S-Chip entitlement is designed to come from a cigarette tax. Tax those dirty smokers and our kids will get free health care! It's a win-win! Yeah! But if we have resolve to tax smokers, and maybe we should, then why give the revenue to middle class families, many of whom already have insurance? The phenomenon of “crowd out” is when the initiation or expansion of a government benefit leads to the substitution of private payers for the said government program. Additionally, sin taxes such as this often result in lower than expected revenues as the sinners change their behaviors and engage in bootlegging untaxed contraband. Furthermore the increased need for law enforcement against bootleggers adds external costs thus depleting net revenue available. (I realize this was accounted for in the CBO Report.)

  2. The Emotional Plea. “Yea but, it's fer da kidz.” The problem I see with S-Chip as designed is that it provides no limits to the number of kids covered. Ten kids, no problem. Sure, it's not the kids' fault and they shouldn't suffer. The current S-Chip grant covers “da kidz”, all of them, up to 200% of poverty. That's enough. If private donors want to cover middle class families, then go for it.

  3. The Fiscal Responsibility Appeal. “Covering kids' health is cost-effective.” Providing routine care for kids saves society money in the long run. I would point out that the same argument is used for people in every age group: health maintenance is cost effective for all of us, so why give kids preferential treatment over adults? Especially kids whose parents are able to provide the insurance themselves.



Peter Drucker, the venerable economist and management expert, spent his life dissecting all manner of industries and determining the market forces involved. Macro forces as well as micro forces, labor issues, corporate governance, government interventions-- nothing was not examined. He was the author of 38 books, including many textbooks, was a contributor to and editor of numerous economic journals as well as the Wall Street Journal. In other words, he knew his shit. When asked about medical economics, however, Drucker was at a loss. The allocation of medical resources is made difficult by competing market forces and incentives (will a surgeon always recommend surgery?) and compounded by the asymmetry of market information (but the ads on CBS News say I need treatment for Restless Leg Syndrome and Toenail Fungus Disorder), the difficulty of assessing quality and the economic stresses of the employer-based insurance model (“I'll give you a raise if you opt out of the costly health insurance benefit.”) None of these problems have simple solutions.



As an anonymous commenter to the last entry has pointed out (although they failed to provide references), other economists such as Ken Arrow and more recently Uwe Reinhardt have also attempted to understand the health care morass. Reinhardt, with whose work I am quite familiar, has written extensively on the single-payer system and has written a Primer which compared the two Presidential candidates' plans in 2004. European nations and Canada have a greater percentage of health costs paid by the government versus the US, and a greater number of citizens covered by either governmental or private health insurance, and the Institute of Medicine has intimated that US quality of care is poor even though we pay a much greater percentage of our GDP on health care. Many folks much smarter than I am have devoted their careers to medical economics and I certainly don't pretend to know the answers.



Health care will be the defining issue of the next few election cycles. The consciousness being raised over the S-Chip expansion and the subsequent Bush veto is the beginning of a long overdue national discussion about health care coverage. My aspiration is that this leads to some type of universal health coverage and not just some lousy expansion of Medicaid, which is really what S-Chip is. My random observations about the current system:

  1. Means-testing needs to be revamped. Why do we only look at income? Conceivably an individual or family that has considerable property wealth but has a median income could qualify for welfare type benefits. This is not as much a problem when using 100% or 200% of the poverty level for income, but at an income of 60-70K, such as engendered in the proposed S-Chip expansion, the abuse potential increases since many of these families may have earned significant incomes and accumulated uncounted wealth. As I mentioned in the previous post, MiChild in Michigan relies on self-reported income, which is inadequate. Also, father's and even grandparents' income should be included in any means calculation, regardless of marital or co-habitation status.

  2. The risk pool needs to be expanded. Of the 44 million Americans who are not covered by health insurance at any given time, many of them are working and some are quite well-off. Often, healthy individuals will opt out of coverage to save money and then opt in when they are older or acquire an illness. This defeats the idea of a risk pool. Health insurance should be mandatory just like auto insurance. Doctors and Emergency Departments cannot “opt out” of treating a sick or injured person depending on their odds of getting paid, so every member of society has a moral obligation to be covered for such a liability. Even the poorer folks who are under-employed and have no employer benefits should be compelled to pay something-- either in the form of a payroll tax and/or a consumption tax-- and then be covered by a basic, government subsidized policy, or even better, with a universal health care plan. Nationalized health in some form, however unlikely to be popular among Bushies, would fulfill all these requirements.

  3. We are a rich country. Most people on Medicaid and S-Chip benefit greatly from these programs and deserve coverage. It's a very generous program. I don't mean to sound shrill about “kicking all the bums off welfare” and such because these programs are very necessary. I do find it odd, however, the numbers of folks I see who have hundreds of dollars of tattoos and nicer cell phones than I do, while they assume little of the responsibility for their necessities. We live in a very wealthy society and the dividends of such wealth and excess are obviously enjoyed by all socio-economic strata. One could argue that the poorest person in 21st Century America is better off than the English nobility of a mere century or two ago. We live longer, drink cleaner water, have vaccines and lower infant mortality, etc. This enormous wealth could be used much more effectively to provide for even more people.

  4. S-Chip pays Medicaid wages. Let's be clear on this. S-Chip is NOT insurance. Of the 35 Ob/Gyns in this county, only a handful accept Medicaid and S-Chip coverage. Why? Because the reimbursement is about 18 cents on the dollar-- not enough to cover overhead expenses. Medicaid and S-Chip may be called “insurance”, but they are actually welfare programs and health care providers only agree to see such patients as a service to the community. Physicians literally lose money for every Medicaid patient they see in the office, and if that patient number increases significantly and detracts from the numbers of privately insured patients, ie, "crowd out", then the pressures on primary care providers will mount. Even Uwe Reinhardt, the proponent for a single payer system, has recognized that such draconian discrepancies in reimbursement are unwarranted and harmful to the health of the system. Dr. Reinhardt (page 16) says:

My own reservation about these two public programs has been that the fees they pay providers tend to be unreasonably low, often not even covering the providers' costs. Not surprisingly, many physicians simply refuse to accept Medicaid patients, an option, however, that is not practical for hospitals.




I would agree with the erudite Dr. Reinhardt and I would go one step further. I feel that physicians taking care of the indigent should be paid more, like combat pay, than those taking care of the more wealthy. (Yeah, I'm a dreamer.) If we want to raise an additional cigarette tax, or any other consumption tax, then why not put that revenue toward proper reimbursement for providers who currently care for the truly indigent?

So the next time someone refers to S-Chip and its proposed expansion as insurance, please feel free to correct them of their delusion. And then ask yourself if a family at 300% of the poverty level and untold other assets should qualify.